Welcome Peeps and Creeps!

Reviews

Rate Show
Absolutely awesome!
I listen to a lot of true crime podcasts and this is by far the BEST new one I’ve heard recently. Perfect amount of information and back-and-forth banter; stories that aren’t covered nearly as often; and you can also tell it’s not super scripted and I really like their personalities! I love the premise too, of a true crime creeper dishing it all to a newbie. Keep it up ladies I’m DEFINITELY a fan!! From a fellow Kentuckian 💙
For All Peeps & Creeps
Kristin and Mogab are phenomenal. Kristin’s research is well done and her synopsis is very succinct and informative. While telling the story - Mogab does NOT feel like merely the sidekick with stunted overdramatic gasps and random, forced questions of why; how come; did they? I also love that most of the stories that Kristin shares are either new-to-me. Or when they are tales I have heard before - it’s not the same regurgitation of information. A huge pet peeve of mine is when the narrators mispronounce words - especially words they use a lot. Thankfully these ladies do not. And of course, a massive plus in their favor is that their voices are not “annoying” or “whiny”. I don’t know how else to stress the fact that you should be listening to True Crime Creepers if you enjoy listening to intelligent people talking about factual, true crime with minimal sidetracking in a witty, well-thought out presentation.
Love the storytelling and the commentary!
I was a little skeptical about the concept of one person telling the true crime stories to someone who hadn't heard it for a reaction...but with these two, it works! Kristin does an amazing job of researching the stories and telling them in a way that gives you all the facts, but also captures the human interest. I also really appreciate that when things get off topic she brings them back quickly/edits the conversation so we stay on the story. I started listening about 8 months into the podcast's life so maybe this wasn't the case at the beginning, but Mogab is a newbie to the stories Kristin is telling, but not to the true crime game. Her commentary is funny and insightful and while I have heard of most of the cases this podcast covers, I still really enjoyed hearing about them the way these ladies present them. I also learned some new things about some of these cases that the Investigation Discovery channel did NOT tell me! Congrats ladies, I can't wait to hear more! 🔪
Entertaining and Hilarious
I LOVE this podcast. Kristin and Mogab are hilarious and their banter is super entertaining. I love hearing all the details Kristin has researched because it’s a lot more than you hear in the news. Can’t get enough of this!!
Favorite true crime podcast!
Love the dynamic between Kristin and Mogab! The cases are also really interesting and with the two of them its even better. It's me and my girlfriends go to podcast for all our drives. 😊
My Not-So-Guilty Pleasure
This podcast if fan-fricken-tastic. Kristin is incredibly intelligent and I love her insightful deep dives. Mogab is adorably aghast, as she learns about these cases, many of which she’s hearing for the firs time…somehow. If you’re a true crime fanatic: This. Podcast. Is. For. YOU!!
My new favorite!
I listen to a lot of different true crime podcasts and I am so glad I discovered this one! I usually don’t like a tone of banter but I could listen to these gals all day long. It’s also a plus that I’m also from the Houston area and can relate so much to a lot of the places they reference. Definitely my new favorite podcast! #byepeepsandcreeps #answerforyourcrimes
My new best friends that just don’t know it yet
I love this podcast! Great banter, but just the right amount so you get to love the hosts without being annoyed by them, well-told and well-researched stories, awesome nostalgic pop culture references. Definitely my new favorite, I only wish there were more because I’m all caught up!
Amazing
I truly love this podcast! I love that they don’t do the crimes as other shows. The girls are amazing. They keep it very interesting. Not a lot of small talk!
UNTIL NOW
I have been looking for months for a new true crime podcast. I have one that I listen to and love it and have not found one yet that holds a candle to it. UNTIL NOW! I love the back and forth between the hosts and it is well researched. I hope you keep going and look forward to future episodes.
new favorite
i love this podcast so much!
Newest Obsession
My new fave podcast to binge! Love dynamic of Kristen and Mogab :)
Best Nancy Grace impressions
I adore these ladies! Their chemistry is epic. It’s one of my favorite pods. Facts and humor what else could you ask for?
Balanced true crime
Found this podcast because you did the special on Adnan —which I loved!! It’s hard to find one that is about true crime yet lighthearted and witty at the same time, I enjoy the banter these ladies share! Keep doing what you’re doing :)
Love the Stories
Very entertaining and engaging.
A Must Listen To
I love listening to this podcast while working out! Sometimes I even extend my time at the gym so I can listen to more!
Addicted
I wasn’t sure at first what I thought, but now I’m binging like CRAZY. I love the stories even though I know most of them already because I love their banter.
My favorite true crime podcast
Rating this podcast anything less than a 5 is a crime. I listen to this every week the day it comes out without fail and haven’t missed an episode. I found them via a TikTok podcast recommendation and I’m obsessed to say the least. Kristin is super knowledgeable about the topics and mogab ads fun commentary and makes it feel like she is learning with you. This is by far my favorite podcast and true crime source, I’ll even listen to repeat cases just because I love the dynamic so much!!
Let’s Get Real
This podcast is original because it’s made for the true crime enthusiast& the first time joiner. Each episode balances facts & details with funny antidotes that keeps it fresh for the true crime veterans & real funny for the newbies. I listen because I find both the storytelling of the crime & the dialogue throughout authentic and intriguing. I LOVE the podcast for the demands for people to ANSWER FOR YOUR CRIMES. It’s given at every level from the villain, to the poor investigative work, to the neighbor, and to the media. I love that when any year is given, I get a short & comedic update on what was cool that year and what the hosts were doing (peaking in high school, working at the Waffle, using a pager, etc.) just to get us ready for the rest of the story. And I really can’t stop laughing at the Nancy Grace (and honestly any) impressions. This is the only podcast I’ve really stuck with & I so look forward to new episodes each week!
Review
Love these ladies!
Soooo Good
This Texas girl absolutely loves this podcast. I feel like I am listening to my best girlfriends discuss my favorite subject of true crime. I am always entertained and NEVER disappointed in an episode. I look forward to the new episode every Thursday. I haven’t missed one yet and NEVER plan to!
Always excited for Thursday!!
I 🤍these ladies! Kristin’s true crime knowledge & Mogab’s innocence is a perfect combination. I also love the mixture of stories… sometimes it’s “nosy with the lights on”, “fyre for lyfe” or “super creepy”.
Love this podcast
Kristin and Mogab are the best!
Love love love
God I love this podcast so much! You will fall in LOVE with the hosts personalities and chemistry. Do a great job of telling the story while keeping it fun! It’s a bright spot in my week