Reviews

Love

I just heard about this podcast and I’ve been binging episodes for about a week. Love these ladies! They are funny and show a lot of empathy to the victims in their episodes. Really enjoy listening to them!

Jill G A
April 27, 2025

Cool as a Cucumber

There are lots of reasons I love this show. Mogab says everything I’m thinking. She’s witty and hilarious! Very endearing. Kristin beautifully combines facts, empathy and compassion, story-telling, and a sense of humor while maintaining a level, reasonable head and letting her opinion be known without it taking over. Just a perfect pairing. I feel at home listening to them.

Cloheato
April 25, 2025

Best Suprise

I stumbled upon this podcast looking for more info on the Lauren Agee case… I love true crime and this cast is the most fun way to listen. I know that sounds weird- fun and crime, but try it!! The ladies of this cast are so fun they make stories relatable they explain questions we all have and their personalities shine. Love this cast and love the hosts!! Great job ladies. I started from the beginning recently and I’m still in 2020 but I hope yall keep making shows for me to binge for a long long time ❤️

It’s a super fun game
April 25, 2025

Love youuuu all!

Fantastic podcast of the true crime variety. Keep on keepin’ on, gals!

lularoecarridillistone
April 18, 2025

They’re my peeps!

Excellent pod! I thought I was going to be bored hearing the same stories I hear on all the other true crime podcasts BUT- even when it is a story I’ve already heard I love the new spins and different voice the True Crime Creepers apply and I’m absolutely NEVER BORED! I’m full throttle listening and loving every minute! I appreciate the hard work and dedication they show through this excellent podcast.

Marholla
April 16, 2025

Fav true crime pod

100% my fav true crime podcast! Love how Kristen tells stories, she’s so intelligent and considerate. And Mogab is the perfect comic relief. I’ve been listening from the start and it made me well up when I heard your first ad. Im SO happy you guys are finally sponsored—you deserve it!! 🤍🤍🤍

0laura0
April 10, 2025

Favorite Podcast

You two are my absolute favorite!! It feels like I’m listening to my friends talk True Crime and I’m laughing out loud with the humor and funny comments 😁🫶🏻 Mogab is hilarious! Hope you’re feeling better.

TrueCrimeWonderland
April 7, 2025

Love you guys!

You make my day at work go by so much faster! Get well soon Mogab!

Not Ian’s Ho
April 5, 2025

Love these ladies

Such a good podcast these ladies are great at story telling and will make you laugh as well!!

paris4me
April 3, 2025

Kevin can go f himself

Great show. Kev can go f himself is mimicked from everybody loves Raymond. Same set up.

Missashlyy01
March 30, 2025

My favorite true crime podcasts hands down

I had to update my review for Joyce McKinney — I was up miserable with the flu and listening to episode 2 and by the end was literally laughing out loud at the story and the way you told it. So good. Criminal defense attorney (15 years) and true crime enthusiast. I’m so glad I found this podcast — it’s my favorite. I love everything about it. They pick great cases and. Wide range, the amount of details paid to the cases is perfect, their banter is great and not too overdone — just enough, they are not biased for prosecution or defense, extremely entertaining all around. True crime perfection!

Megan Tomlinson attorney
March 29, 2025

Like a chat with your besties!

I stumbled upon this pod a few months ago and have been binging ever since. Even if I know a case backwards and forwards I will still listen to their episode on it just to hear Mogab’s quips. They are so fun to listen to. Keep up the great work!

ELMSop
March 27, 2025

My Favorite True Crime Podcast

The perfect mix of humor and the story!!

tfkayolay
March 27, 2025

New Fave Podcast!

Honestly, this review has been a long time coming, I believe I ran across this podcast through another podcast and I was hooked. I listen to almost 4 years in three months. Absolutely love everything about it and their friendship. Keep up the amazing work, ladies!

Nezza A.
March 27, 2025

My favorite podcast

I found True Crime Creepers as a bit of a podcast newbie when I was trying to find a new podcast after exhausting the first I’ve ever listened to, Tell No One. I was desperately looking for one with the same vibe, and boy did I find better. I love the dynamic and friendship between Kristen and Mogab, their chemistry is contagious. They are fun and entertaining and REAL. I’m listening back and currently in 2023 loving all of Mogab’s wedding talk. Mogab I hope everything is ok. We miss you and can’t wait for you to come back when you’re ready. Kristen, in the last episode you said someone told you to stop yelling at them in a review. Please never stop being the passionate, caring person you are. Pop off Queen. Love you both, next stop PATRON! 🖤

BeccaBowers
March 25, 2025

Crime time fun!

Kristin brings out great info from each case, and Mogab always brings the fun! These 2 banter back and forth and keep it interesting! Take a listen! You will learn something new!

jsgreen1118
March 24, 2025

Like hanging with friends

True Crime Creepers is the perfect balance of respect for the stories being told, introspection, and goofy fun. Kristen and Mogab add to this by balancing each other with their different personalities, bringing a diversity of thoughts and reactions to the episodes. I also appreciate that there is a broad spectrum of stories told- including fraud, heists, and survival sorties. I’m a patron on patreon for a reason (bonus episodes, mini episodes, ad free). Five stars for sure.

ELOELO@&&
March 21, 2025

Best True Crime Podcast!

Kristin and Mogab have become my driving buddies. I listen on my commute and love this podcast! I really appreciate the way they tell people’s stories. They are sensitive to the victims and the loved ones who were affected. And I also appreciate how they don’t go into too many gory details. They give the necessary information without overly dramatizing the crimes. I’ve listened to all the back episodes and look forward to the new ones. Definitely worth subscribing!

C.F.W.
March 21, 2025

❤️

Such a great show! It’s like having a conversation with two of my best friends. The cases are presented perfectly and the commentary helps balance it out. Love it!

MLE 25
March 7, 2025

Love to listen

Such a great podcast! Love Kristin and Mogab and their presentation of the cases.

Noelle B
March 2, 2025

All

I’m not a holy-than-though person, but it is so refreshing to not hear the F-word scattered through the podcast. These two actually make me laugh out loud. Plus I appreciate that the diversions into personal stories are short-lived but still entertaining. First time I’ve ever left a review for a podcast!

untitled 5
March 2, 2025

🫶🏻

Genuinely one of my favorite crime podcasts!! My best friend recommended y’all’s podcast in early 2024 and I’ve been an avid listener since then. I really appreciate how much time and care you put into researching the cases you talk about!! You guys remind me a lot of my best friend and I. And I love that so much haha. Also I LOVE that your cat is named after Mr. Darcy. Such a slay ❤️

Elizabeth Fern
March 1, 2025

Power pod woman

The work that you put into this podcast writing and reading is something to experience. I love listening to amazing rapport really great information.

1eyedear
Feb. 27, 2025

My Peeps

Creep for life! Great dynamic between hosts and the stories are told and discussed in an interesting, entertaining and respectful manner. All the stars. Thank you!

&rae
Feb. 23, 2025

One of my favorites now

Just discovered you two & I’m hooked!

Bee9393
Feb. 8, 2025

Love this podcast!

Such a great podcast, every episode is so well thought out and the stories are told perfectly.

Don’t touch my pow pows
Jan. 27, 2025

Girls. You have moved my soul.

I stumbled upon your podcast by accident, I was caught up on my other two favs. And, listen, there are some awful podcasts out there people! Good Lawrd! I listened to one of True Crime Creepers, and was hooked. I went back and started at the very beginning. So, for the last month y’all have been my new best friends. Today Kristin, you made me cry! At work! (Shhh, y’all are off limits at work, so don’t let anyone know you’re in my ear!) but Kristin! I can’t be bawlin’ at work! The West Memphis Three. You did an amazing job. You’re ending, with the hug between the guys. It was so moving. Definitely a 5 star episode. So, I’ll soon be caught up, so I had to jump on the Patreon so I can continue on, I don’t want to be left out on any fun! Thank you both for filling my days with laughter, enlightening cases and on occasion, tears. Keep up the great work! (Sorry Mogab, I know you threaten to quit, but it would never be the same without you!) much respect & love!

Khristen Pari
Jan. 21, 2025

My favorite true crime podcasts hands down

Criminal defense attorney (15 years) and true crime enthusiast. I’m so glad I found this podcast — it’s my favorite. I love everything about it. They pick great cases and. Wide range, the amount of details paid to the cases is perfect, their banter is great and not too overdone — just enough, they are not biased for prosecution or defense, extremely entertaining all around. True crime perfection!

Megan Tomlinson attorney
Jan. 20, 2025

Loyal fan

I’ve tried a few true crime and supernatural shows and keep coming back to your show. I love the stories you select and how you tell those stories. 👍🏼

: BATMAN :
Dec. 21, 2024

Great podcast!

Found this and are now bingeing episodes! They do a deep dive into cases and do it with humor. Love the banter.

stacy372
Dec. 13, 2024