Welcome Peeps and Creeps!

Reviews

Rate Show

Great Recommendation
New listener here. Heard promo on No One Should Believe Me. Great coverage and victim focused. I’ll be back to binge for sure!

Pretty fantastic
I heard about these two from “Nobody Should Believe Me”, and not only does Kristin do openminded and curious research (reading original court documents to answer questions that she feels stumped by), but she is very easy to listen to and does a superlative Nancy Grace impression. The hosts don’t do too much banter, especially at the top of episodes: I like it when podcasts dive right in—you can hear rapport during the discussion of the topic under consideration. Mogab offers a respectfully interested neophyte foil to Kristin’s deep dives (but I wish she sounded less liquid and would swallow more before she speaks). The two of them seem charmingly charmed by each other, and their dynamic is warm and comfortable. I *never* thought I could be a Scott Peterson truther, and yet Kristin has shown me how many conclusions I jumped to (even if the evidence for his innocence is not conclusive). This podcast is pretty fantastic: I’ve listened to a few eps and am very happy to have found them. Surprised they don’t have more reviews ♥️

I’m a true crime newbie too!
Never listened to any true crime pod before this and never knew how much I’d get sucked in! So many of these episodes had me gasping in shock

Well done and hilarious!
I found this podcast after someone in the Let's Go to Court Podcast Facebook Group recommended it. I was impressed. The research is excellent and respectful to the victims. Kristin and Mogab have a natural flow of conversation that makes you feel comfortable. I’ve heard most of the stories before; however, Mogab’s reaction makes the retelling entertaining. 5/5 ❤️

Perfection
This duo is incredible. Witty, respectful, hilarious, well researched! Their dynamic works seamlessly. Love love love!

Silly, creepy and true crime stories
I just listened to “The Murder of Abraham Shakespeare!” Oh my goodness! Deedee has to be the worst liar of all liars! I laughed so hard! Y’all are the best!

Silly, creepy and true crime stories
This is the best way to start my day. Kristin and Mogab are so good at telling stories and are so funny while being serious at the same time. Check them out, you won’t be disappointed!

It’s like listening to your best friends
I absolutely LOVE you girls!! I stumbled across the podcast and I have binged y’all’s episodes starting from the very beginning!! Keep up the good work.

Best of the Best as for True Crime
The lovely Mogab and Kristin have gotten me through many long train rides & gloomy days. They have a beautiful, positive, refreshing perspective on some of the best cases. Although many pods do these cases, their commentary, humor, and personal touches are why this podcast has quickly become my personal favorite & one of the only 2 I actually pay for, Patreon-wise. Their Patreon is also super cool as they send you a signed card & give you a shout out on the pod. Truly love this podcast and hope the rest of the world realizes soon enough.

One of my favs!!
This podcast is one of my favs, and I’m a picky listener haha! Kristen is a great storyteller and Mogab just cracks me up. Great dynamic between these friends. Keep up the good work girls, and don’t change anything for anyone!!

Great podcast!
I have no idea why more people don’t know about this podcast. It’s great!!!! Solid storytelling and the gals keep it fun. Keep up the awesome work!

Binge this show!! 🤩👏🏼👏🏼
I love spending my workouts (and let’s be honest… cleaning the house, being a mom, working my business, etc) with Kristin and Mogab! I found the show a month ago and I’ve blown through almost 100 episodes. I’m so sad already thinking about what I’ll do when I don’t have any more eps to binge 😂 Love the storytelling and the banter. It really feels like you are sitting with these girls, having a cocktail and chatting about all these crazy stories.

Easily my favorite pod!
This is my favorite podcast of all time! These ladies have such amazing chemistry and listening each week is like catching up with friends while enjoying Kristin’s storytelling! The episodes are very well written and keep me hooked each week. Mogab is so freakin cute and relatable and hysterical. Love you ladies!!

Love this show!
I’ve been listening to the show for a few years now and am hooked. I started because I was looking for information on a true crime that took place in the town where I live. Now it’s one of the best parts of the week, when a new episode drops. I continue to look forward to these well researched and informative takes on the stories and lives of those that I have never heard of. I’ve turned everyone in my friend group on to the show as well. Teachers, SAHMs, engineers, artists, and writers… we all love how entertaining the show is! And my boyfriend is now hooked and a fan as well! We all love talking about the episodes and how genuine the relationship between Kristin and Mogab is. So many of Mogab’s one liners have been added to our own group chats! These two are so likable and relatable, like two more friends in the group. I would encourage anyone who loves true crime, down-to-earth lighthearted humor and quick whit, and overall just a good time, to go ahead and listen to this podcast. Oh and they hand out discounts left and right on awesome products… and ya girl here loves a discount!

Too Many Ads
Having to skip through 5 minutes of ads three times per episode seems a little money-hungry to me when you’ve already got an expensive Patreon, but otherwise a pretty good podcast

Love it all!!
The hosts are great, their banter and personalities, and their story telling. I binged the entire pod over a few months and can’t wait for more!! I am so happy to have stumbled on this pod. It’s my new favorite and surpasses other crime pods I have in my rotation.

Love the podcast
Loveeee this podcast

Love these 2!
I have loved this podcast since it’s inception. I’m not one to usually leave reviews; but after reading a few of the negative nellie reviews- I just had to say something. Just in case anyone needs this explained to them here it goes: if you want more in-depth coverage or never before heard information, don’t rely on an hour long podcast to fill that need. IT’S A FLIPPIN PODCAST, ie it’s for ENTERTAINMENT (and entertaining it is!). Perhaps my biggest pet peeve a History/Historic preservation major are people who feel the need to humble-brag that they have a college degree. OMG they have a Liberal Arts degree they definitely know so much about about the world, and should totally insult random podcasters on what they are doing wrong (I’m sure anybody with an English Lit degree will understand that last sentence was sarcasm, but just in case-that was sarcasm). This podcast is funny. It has good information, keeps cases that are unsolved talked about, they have great banter, and I can tell they are great friends. I think they are awesome. I will keep listening to it. We all have choices in this life. You can choose to listen to this podcast, you choose not to listen to it; but leaving a humble-braggy, passive aggressive review of a random podcast is probably not the best choice to make.

Love these 2
Not gonna lie, I came here to read Liz’s review 😂 BUT I have been listening to you guys since the beginning and I absolutely love this podcast! I love the dynamic between Kristin and Mogab… they are both so funny. The stories are interesting, well researched, and well told. I feel like you guys would be my besties irl! ❤️🦝

Love these 2!
I have loved this podcast since it’s inception. I’m not one to usually leave reviews; but after reading a few of the negative nellie reviews- I just had to say something. Just in case anyone needs this explained to them here it goes: if you want more in-depth coverage or never before heard information, don’t rely on an hour long podcast to fill that need. IT’S A FLIPPIN PODCAST, ie it’s for ENTERTAINMENT (and entertaining it is!). Perhaps my biggest pet peeve a History/Historic preservation major are people who feel the need to humble-brag that they have a college degree. OMG they have a Liberal Arts degree they definitely know so much about about the world, and should totally insult random podcasters on what they are doing wrong (I’m sure anybody with an English Lit degree will understand that last sentence was sarcasm, but just in case-that was sarcasm). This podcast is funny. It has good information, keeps cases that are unsolved talked about, they have great banter, and I can tell they are great friends. I think they are awesome. I will keep listening to it. We all have choices in this life. You can choose to listen to this podcast, you choose not to listen to it; but leaving a humble-braggy, passive aggressive review of a random podcast is probably not the best choice you could’ve made.

Love these 2!
I have loved this podcast since it’s inception. I’m not one to usually leave reviews; but after reading a few of the negative nellie reviews- I just had to say something. Just in case anyone needs this explained to them here it goes: if you want more in-depth coverage or never before heard information, don’t rely on an hour long podcast to fill that need. IT’S A FLIPPIN PODCAST, ie it’s for ENTERTAINMENT (and entertaining it is!). Perhaps my biggest pet peeve a History/Historic preservation major are people who feel the need to humble-brag that they have a college degree. OMG they have a Liberal Arts degree they definitely know so much about about the world, and should totally insult random podcasters on what they are doing wrong (I’m sure anybody with an English Lit degree will understand that last sentence was sarcasm, but just in case-that was sarcasm). This podcast is funny. It has good information, keeps cases that are unsolved talked about, they have great banter, and I can tell they are great friends. I think they are awesome. I will keep listening to it. We all have choices in this life. You can choose to listen to this podcast, you choose not to listen to it; but leaving a humble-braggy, passive aggressive review of a random podcast is probably not the best choice you could’ve made.

l LOVE THIS PODCAST!!
I was looking for a case the other day when I stumbled upon this podcast, so I decided to start from the first ever episode. Kristin is what everyone’s idea of the perfect bestie is and Mogab is literally me, I catch myself asking questions at the same time or saying “oh” when she does cause it makes sense lol even though a few of these cases I have already heard, I got so much information even I didn’t know. Thank you guys for doing what you do! I 10/10 recommend this podcast if you are looking for entertainment and a true crime

Love
I love this podcast was looking for something between crime junkie and morbid and this fit the bill exactly. It’s easily my favorite podcast now.

Love them!
They are great and so much fun to listen to, even though the topics are true crime. They have such a natural easy to listen to format. Love them

Love this podcast! It’s my new obsession
This podcast is so addicting and has ruined me from wanting to listen to others ones. I feel they are my best friends.

All the love
Love listening to y’all!

True crime lover
Quickly became obsessed with Kristin and Mogab! Love the banter. Love that Mogab knows barely any true crime stories and love her reactions. Even though I know most of the stories, I love getting extra details from Kristin.

Well Researched
It’s obvious that Kristin does a great deal of research for each episode. The incidents are well reported and obscenities are rare. I think I might have heard one obscenity once and that is unusual and much appreciated when compared to other podcasts where the f word is used for every other word. Not only does Kristin cite her references, she thanks them for the work that they did. Nice work!

Hooked!
Stumbled upon this gem of a podcast by way of their Mickey Shunick episode - wow. You feel the hosts’ genuine frustration, anger & sadness, and the humor is organic, inoffensive & quite frankly, needed. Looking forward to bingeing past episodes & hearing their take on both familiar and unfamiliar victims & their stories.

Love it !
I really enjoy how detailed you are into these cases & the back & forth banter between the two of you is TOP TIER chefs kiss.