Listener Reviews

They make me feel like I’m sitting in on a convo with friends. Perfect blend of humor, empathy, and good storytelling

These ladies are THE BEST at telling stories respectfully but humorously. If you like (the old/original) Morbid, My Favorite Murder, etc., you’ll love it. I’d never thought twice about Scott Peterson and the POSSIBILITY of his innocence until the facts I heard here, confirmed by lots of further research. The empathy in the Andrea Yates episode made me cry. And you’re right, Lou Pearlman DOES look like a thumb. I also love that they’re from my hometown area and then went to college just south of where I did (UT Austin vs Texas State/frmly SWT) so a lot of the references are local. Hook em, and Eat em Up Cats.

This is my new favorite podcast. I’m so happy I stumbled upon it. They remind me of the girls from Sinisterhood. Very underrated - can’t wait for new episodes!

I enjoy the banter (and I normally hate tangents during a story) but I do appreciate the commentary with these two. I’m about to go ahead binge this show.

I love you gals. You always. Are me laugh and you do a great job in telling these stores.

I love the two parters. I prefer the deep dives vs. a 20 minute story. I like to be absorbed into a story. This podcast delivers. One of my favorites for sure.

I’m on episode 2 I already love the podcast! I was trying to find a good true crime podcast after I stopped listening to morbid. I finally found one that I enjoy listening to!

100% my fav true crime podcast! Love how Kristen tells stories, she’s so intelligent and considerate. And Mogab is the perfect comic relief. SO happy to have her back from her wedding hiatus. I’ve been listening from the start and it made me well up when I heard your first ad. Im SO happy you guys are getting paid to do this podcast—you deserve it!! 🤍🤍🤍

Omggggg I loveeee you guys. My new favorite. Please don’t ever leave me 🤣

So glad I found this!

Great show but K needs to get it together with her 90’s country.

One day I was randomly searching for a podcast to listen to and I found this one. One episode, that’s all I needed to become obsessed. I needed to listen from the beginning to the most recent, it’s all I listen to on my free time. I’m telling everyone that I know that listens to podcast to listen to it. I love it.

You covered this horrific story with integrity, unlike Hulu or netflix. Sure framing it as a possible “orphan” scenario is more gripping, but absolutely disgusting. Natalia was a victim of the Barnetts and the whole system. They should’ve gone to prison. I like your fire!

My new favorite! Fantastic storytelling, lovable ladies! Great topic choices.

This is my favorite, true crime podcast, because I love how we get to hear all the nitty-gritty dirty details about each crime, but it is lightened up a bit Thanks to the witty banter of these two hosts. Kristin’s impressions of Nancy Grace make me LOL and Mowgab is so funny with her reactions. I also love her stories about Louise. Keep it up guys.

As a fellow skeezy scunch I’m always looking for another podcast that’s up to LGTC level and I’m glad this one was shared in the LGTC Fb group. I’m loving the coverage and the girls work so well together!

I discovered True Crime Creepers from an episode of True Crime Binge and it has become my favorite podcast. I love the sincerity of Kristin and Mogab and their chemistry. You can just tell how much heart Kristin has as she tells the stories. If we ever cross paths, a pitcher of sangria is coming your way!

Destiny was such a great guest co-host. She reminds me of Mogab, with her questions and jokes. The three of you should do a story together. Great job “not Mogab!”

So glad I found this podcast! Love the dynamic between the 2 ladies.

You covered this horrific story with integrity, unlike Hulu or netflix. Sure framing it as a possible “orphan” scenario is more gripping, but absolutely disgusting. Natalia was a victim of the Barnetts and the whole system. They should’ve gone to prison.

Mogab and Kristin have a very charming rapport. I like hearing them talk about a lot of crimes/mysteries that I haven’t heard of before. They are compassionate and passionate, warm and informed. Hard recommend.

I listen to a lot of true crime podcasts and am constantly looking for new ones that I haven’t listened to before. I found this one and instantly knew it was a keeper! If you like the banter and interesting stories this one is for you too!! Sketchy people doing sketchy things 🤓

True crime creepers is one of my favorite podcasts! I love Kristin and Mogab!

I listen to dozens upon dozens of podcasts regularly, and this is my favorite weekly one. The relationship between the hosts, the hosts’ ability to comfortably be themselves, and their takes on pretty much everything are spot on. Kristen and Mogab, I’m close to 20 years older than you, with young teenagers, and I’d be thrilled if they grew up to be as open and honest and compassionate as you are. (They are already well on their way.) Thank you for putting yourselves out there. xo